perceptions of the significance of science and research
Whenever I read an article on a scientific study or research, I notice comments from some people who disagree with the findings. Many of these comments are from people who choose to do the following:
1) Insult the findings of the researchers as common sense or stupid without elaborate or intelligent explanation as to why the findings are either of those things.
2) Insult the researchers’ education/degrees, the institution where they were obtained or other ad hominem attacks.
3) Question how much and why money was spent on the research. This seems to be a very constant theme among comments like these. These comments often suggest that the money should be spent on something else and often makes an implication that the government is wasting the money on research.
4) State that the research cannot possibly be true because it has not happened to them.
Many times, the insults to the research do not even address the research at all. I’ve seen comments insulting the intellectual capacity of scientists who have completed research for decades and have seen M.I.T. and Harvard referred to as stupid schools. Sometimes private organizations (often listed in the articles) fund the studies so government funding is not applicable to the study in question. Furthermore, studies take into account many subjects, unless longitudinal with a solo subject.
I will admit that my first reaction to people who comment this way is “oh, what an idiot.” But maybe it is more than that. The people who comment this way seem to distrust both the government and science and think that research is a waste of time and money. This is not to say that the government should be trusted implicitly, or that some research is completely unethical and immoral. All I have to do is think of Tuskegee to know that. However, it seems very consistent that articles that report on research findings are attacked in this manner, almost as if science within itself is a lie.
And it is quite the paradox. When research confirms widely held beliefs, the article on the research is attacked as common sense. When someone states beliefs without proper research or just on observation alone, their beliefs/article is attacked for not having research to support it. So which is it? Is research a bad thing, utilizing money that should be allocated somewhere else or should research be involved in supporting articles and statements?
I realize that some people simply want to disagree with whatever is written in an article. Some find power in disagreement. Some people are in fact idiots and simply rude. But it seems that a larger group simply distrusts science in general. They seem to not be able to find any value in research, as they cannot envision how advancements in science has impacted their daily lives, although it has in so many ways. For some people, it seems that an experience has to truly be personal and affect them personally for it to matter. Though some psychological research in depression may seem like common sense, it may help millions of people, although it may not help the reader. Though research in chemotherapy may help those suffering from cancer, it may not help the reader. Though research in social media behavior may help companies market better, increase revenue and employ more people, it may not help the reader.
The comments that I see reek of fear and distrust of science and a personal selfishness that is really dangerous in a society as interconnected as we are. Although individualistic thought and behavior is apart of our cultural fabric and is believed to make people stronger, it can also be a detriment and completely toxic. People should not get to a point where they view any money spent on research as an automatic waste, and think that people are stupid for either wanting to help others or for simply having a curious mind. Unfortunately, I believe that many people do have the aforementioned beliefs, and it’s unfortunate indeed.
Related Blog Posts: gods, devils and men, what's she gonna do, take my picture?




Comments [0]